高苗's profileGaoMiaoPhotosBlogLists Tools Help

Blog


    2/6/2007

    以史为镜

    史书读的不多,部分原因是小时候读过通俗易懂的上下五千年,就以为史书无非就是把同样的故事换种方式再说一遍罢了。但慢慢发现,即使是同样的故事,在不同的作者笔下读出来的滋味也不尽相同,何况历史本身就含有很多的不确定性,谁能保证史书中每一个细节都经得起反复的推敲呢?谁又能说明白是是非非对于如果在当事人的处境到底孰是孰非呢?不过这些抛开暂且不论,单说精彩的著作,读到投入时本身就是一件很享受的事情,特别是有些人会用通俗的言辞把历史写的很过瘾,读起来更让人欲罢不能。

    同样是写明史,当年明月的《明朝那些事儿》与黄仁宇先生的《万历十五年》就是两种截然的风格,但却各有各的妙处。当年明月的书是现在网络上得到追捧,凭借睿智如评书般的语言把明王朝的风雨兴衰讲述的耐人寻味,读来犹如当年初看另一本网络著作《量子物理史话》那般痛快。不必看几个章节,就会沉迷于作者笔下明朝正史的精彩,读到尽兴,时而掩卷沉思,时而击节赞叹。书中写到的人物个个栩栩如生,从朱元璋到朱棣,从刘伯温到徐达,从胡惟庸到方孝孺,无不给人留下鲜活的印象,书中常提到的性格决定命运,每每在史书记载中得到印证时,往往也是让人不胜唏嘘。

    而黄仁宇先生的著作,则以万历十五年这个特定时间点的历史事件和人物为中心,抽丝剥茧般把明史的细节和启发阐述的淋漓尽致。基于这个时间原点,细细梳理中国封建社会统治管理阶层存在种种问题的根源和影响,并在此基础上探索应当汲取的经验和教训,其详尽论述之处,堪与费孝通先生的《江村经济》相媲美。正如作者所言“叙事不妨细致,但是结论却要看远不顾近”,看的透彻,其实现实就是改写后的历史,如今的故事只是换种形式又一次轮回罢了。

    正如当年明月所说:历史本身很精彩,历史可以写得很好看。正是能写出每个人眼中都可以发现精彩的著作,这样的历史才会各有各的可看之处。架子上还积攒着南怀瑾先生的书,买来还一直没有静下心去读,想想深谙国学的南先生笔下,传统中国的历史文化应该更有一番独特韵味。

    Comments

    Please wait...
    Sorry, the comment you entered is too long. Please shorten it.
    You didn't enter anything. Please try again.
    Sorry, we can't add your comment right now. Please try again later.
    To add a comment, you need permission from your parent. Ask for permission
    Your parent has turned off comments.
    Sorry, we can't delete your comment right now. Please try again later.
    You've exceeded the maximum number of comments that can be left in one day. Please try again in 24 hours.
    Your account has had the ability to leave comments disabled because our systems indicate that you may be spamming other users. If you believe that your account has been disabled in error please contact Windows Live support.
    Complete the security check below to finish leaving your comment.
    The characters you type in the security check must match the characters in the picture or audio.

    To add a comment, sign in with your Windows Live ID (if you use Hotmail, Messenger, or Xbox LIVE, you have a Windows Live ID). Sign in


    Don't have a Windows Live ID? Sign up

    Trackbacks

    The trackback URL for this entry is:
    http://tomga.spaces.live.com/blog/cns!4192FFE357D961DA!654.trak
    Weblogs that reference this entry
    • None